Their criteria for greatness was tough: The researchers sought companies that had underperformed the general stock market for at least 15 years, then went through a transition, and subsequently outperformed the general stock market by at least three times for the next 15 years. Starting with 1, companies that appeared on the Fortune list from tothe researchers eventually identified only 11 that made the cut. Although there are other factors involved for taking a company from 'good to great', what these great companies turned out to have in common was a particular kind of leader during the transition period, but it wasn't a headline-grabber like Chrysler's Lee Iacocca or GE's Jack Welch.
Over is the bittersweet sharing of work with relatives. Lessened is the tension of reading out loud to a bunch of strangers.
Writer workshops have gone online! Writers of varying experience and publishing levels are joining online critique groups in droves. Eager to gain objective feedback, helpful hints and wide-flung research resources, writers are committing themselves to helping each other climb the rickety ladder to publishing success.
But are online workshops, and specifically, critique groups, suitable for everyone? Many new writers are often concerned with their ability to provide a good critique.
Good critiquing skills generally come from experience, but if you're lacking in experience how do you learn the Fine Art of the Critique? Let's start with a few pointers: Positive Encouragement New to critiquing or not, it's always a good point to remember to be positive.
Even if you feel Critique on good to great you're pointing out mistakes every few words, do it in a positive manner and it's likely the author won't be offended. Positive encouragement does not mean gushing praise that is not earned. The author can get "gushing" from the relatives. What you need to look for and remember to point out is the word usage that you feel really works, descriptions that you [as reader] really connect to, the good hook at the end that leaves you wanting to read more straight away.
The bits that need work can also be pointed out in a positive way. For example, a sentence may be overly long and wordy, but the basis or concept is very good. Suggest ways that the sentence can be improved to bring out the pearls using positive words: A good way to word your suggestions is to think how you would like such comments to be given to you on your own work.
Constructive Feedback A paragraph or scene isn't working. Suggest to the author ways they might improve the piece. The author wants to know what is good, what needs work and what completely sucks!
Look at the beginning and ending - good hooks, too vague, too slow? Consider POV [point of view], is it working, confused, jumbled? Are the tags working or missing? Structure--are sentences too wordy?
Read them out loud if you're not sure and you'll soon understand what "too wordy" is. If your tongue trips over the words and fumbles around descriptions then the author needs to do some cutting. Other important and common structural errors are sentence length and repetition. Sentences need to be varied, some short, some long and some in between.
If you think they can be divided up into two or three shorter sentences then say so. Action scenes work better with short sentences and short paragraphs, this gives them the punch and impact they require to work well. Repetition is so easy to do and so easy for the author to miss.
Trust your instincts Trust yourself to understand and recognise when a passage isn't working. If you're not sure exactly what to say then think about how the piece affects you as reader.Writing great reviews helps others discover the places that are just right for them.
Here are a few tips: Be informative and insightful: Be specific and relevant to the place you’re reviewing, and describe what other visitors are likely to experience. Highlight what makes the place special, and try . Authors > Articles > Critique view cart. Seven Steps to a Good Critique by Trish Anderson.
Gone are the lonely hours of plodding away at typewriters.
Over is the bittersweet sharing of work with relatives. Writing great reviews helps others discover the places that are just right for them. Here are a few tips: Be informative and insightful: Be specific and relevant to the place you’re reviewing, and describe what other visitors are likely to experience.
Highlight what makes the place special, and try to share something novel and new. Authors > Articles > Critique view cart. Seven Steps to a Good Critique by Trish Anderson. Gone are the lonely hours of plodding away at typewriters.
Over is the bittersweet sharing of work with relatives. A good example is the use of circles to indicate obscure passages, stars to show inconsistencies and underlining to show essential passages.
These are some of the skills that will set you apart from your contemporaries when you`re learning how to critique a research article. Great Critique Doesn’t Happen By Accident Critique is one of the most valuable tools a design team has. Careful thought and consideration on how it’s done is as important as doing it.